Judgement and Writing
No matter what genre your writing, you must judge well. Your judgement is what garners your readers' trust.
Judgement implies deliberation. You decide what is right or best after you have considered all factors. We do not jail people until we have all the facts of a crime.
Judgement requires discipline. The word discipline derives from the Latin discipulus, which means student. To judge well, we must learn to distinguish what is important and what is trivial. We must train our minds to discern. We cannot judge the quality of an apple or what made it sweet if we cannot distinguish an apple from a tomato. Both are red, but color is not the characteristic that makes one distinct from the other.
Discipline implies order and consistency. Consistency arises from experience and often from errors. What served us well, we should repeat in similar situations. When we err, we learn to think or do something differently next time until we find a solution. To be a better writer, practice judging and discerning.
We must judge which words to use. Jacques Barzun, in Simple and Direct: A Manual for Writers, wrote, “The French call mot juste the word that exactly fits. Why is this word so hard to find? The reasons are many. First, we don't always know what we mean and are too lazy too find out.” Discipline implies rigor and energy. We should yield to the temptation to write the first word that comes to mind.
We must judge what is relevant to our topic and what is not. Tangents are useful in calculus but often not for writers. If you diverge from your theme into something that appears irrelevant or a distinct topic be sure that you have good reason to do so.
When describing a scene, we must judge what elements produce the mood. If we judge well, the scene appears in the minds of our readers. If we judge poorly, our readers cannot envision what we describe.
When writing narrative, fiction or nonfiction, we must judge what events are important, what caused the events that we describe. We must judge what motivated our characters or subjects to do what they did. If we judge well, our narratives, characters, and scenes achieve verisimilitude. Our readers believe us.
If we are writing fiction, our readers suspend their disbelief. We have transported them to the world that we have created. We have been successful as writers.